  
  
 | 
 
  | 
  
 Volume 
	8: No. 1, January 2011 
LETTER 
Regression Model Fitting 
		With Quadratic Term Leads to Different Conclusion in Economic Analysis 
		of Washington State Smoking Ban [Response to Letter]
| Quarter/Year | 
Sales in Millions, $ | 
Segmented | 
Quadratic | 
 
| 1/02 | 
96.2 | 
95.9 | 
101.0 | 
 
| 2/02 | 
98.9 | 
95.7 | 
98.7 | 
 
| 3/02 | 
99.5 | 
95.4 | 
96.7 | 
 
| 4/02 | 
95.3 | 
95.2 | 
95.0 | 
 
| 1/03 | 
90.5 | 
95.0 | 
93.5 | 
 
| 2/03 | 
92.1 | 
94.7 | 
92.4 | 
 
| 3/03 | 
93.1 | 
94.5 | 
91.5 | 
 
| 4/03 | 
92.9 | 
94.3 | 
90.9 | 
 
| 1/04 | 
89.4 | 
94.0 | 
90.6 | 
 
| 2/04 | 
92.1 | 
93.8 | 
90.6 | 
 
| 3/04 | 
96.9 | 
93.5 | 
90.9 | 
 
| 4/04 | 
93.7 | 
93.3 | 
91.4 | 
 
| 1/05 | 
91.0 | 
93.1 | 
92.2 | 
 
| 2/05 | 
97.0 | 
92.8 | 
93.3 | 
 
| 3/05 | 
98.6 | 
92.6 | 
94.7 | 
 
| 4/05 | 
97.7 | 
92.4 | 
96.3 | 
 
| 1/06 | 
91.4 | 
92.1 | 
98.3 | 
 
| 2/06 | 
96.3 | 
96.4 | 
100.5 | 
 
| 3/06 | 
99.3 | 
100.8 | 
103.0 | 
 
| 4/06 | 
97.9 | 
105.1 | 
105.8 | 
 
| 1/07 | 
99.7 | 
109.4 | 
108.9 | 
 
| 2/07 | 
114.2 | 
113.7 | 
112.2 | 
 
| 3/07 | 
126.0 | 
118.0 | 
115.8 | 
 
| 4/07 | 
124.2 | 
122.3 | 
119.7 | 
 
 
Figure. Segmented and quadratic regressions fit to 
	taxable retail sales in bars and taverns in Washington State after the 
	implementation of a smoke-free law, from the first quarter of 2002 (1/02) 
	through the fourth quarter of 2007 (4/07). Values are adjusted for inflation 
	to the Consumer Price Index (www.bls.gov/cpi/). 
Return to article 
 | 
 
  |